![]() |
|||
1 |
Plot Overview
Charlie
Gordon is a mentally retarded, 32-year-old man who is chosen by a
team of scientists to undergo an experimental surgery designed to boost his
intelligence. Charlie has been recommended for the experiment by Alice
Kinnian, his teacher at the Beekman College Center for Retarded
Adults, because of his exceptional eagerness to learn. He is asked by the
directors of the experiment, Dr.
Strauss and Professor
Nemur, to keep a journal, and the entire narrative is entirely
composed of the resulting "progress reports."
Charlie works at Donner's
Bakery in New York City as a janitor and delivery boy. The other employees often
taunt him and pick on him, but Charlie is unable to understand that he is the
subject of mockery. He believes that his co-workers are good friends. After a
battery of tests—including a maze-solving competition with a mouse named
Algernon, who has already had the experimental surgery performed on
him—Charlie undergoes the operation. Initially he is disappointed that there
is no immediate change in his intellect, but with work and help from Alice
Kinnian, he gradually begins to improve his spelling and grammar. He begins to
read adult books, slowly at first, and then voraciously, filling his brain with
knowledge from every academic field. He shocks the workers at the bakery by
inventing a process designed to improve productivity. He begins to recover lost
memories of his childhood—most of which involve him being resented, and often
brutally punished, by his mother Rose
for not being normal like the other children.
As Charlie becomes more intelligent, he realizes that he is deeply attracted to
Alice. She insists on keeping their relationship professional, but it is obvious
that she shares Charlie's attraction. When Charlie discovers that one of the
bakery employees is stealing from Mr. Donner, Charlie is uncertain what to do
until Alice tells him to trust his heart. Delighted by the realization that he
is capable of solving moral dilemmas on his own, Charlie confronts the worker
and forces him to stop cheating Donner. Soon after, Charlie is let go from the
bakery, because the other workers are disturbed by the sudden change in Charlie,
and Donner can see that Charlie no longer needs his charity. Charlie grows
closer to Alice, though whenever the mood becomes too intimate, Charlie
experiences a sensation of panic and of being watched by his old retarded self.
He recovers memories of being beaten by Rose for the slightest sexual impulses,
and he realizes that this past trauma is responsible for his inability to make
love to Alice.
Charlie and Algernon travel to Chicago with Strauss and Nemur for a scientific
convention at which they are the star exhibits. Deeply frustrated by Nemur's
refusal to recognize his humanity—Charlie feels that Nemur treats him like
just another lab animal—and troubled by the realization that his scientific
knowledge has advanced beyond Nemur's, Charlie wreaks havoc by freeing Algernon
from his cage while they are on stage. Charlie absconds with Algernon back to
New York, and he gets his own apartment where the scientists cannot find him. He
realizes that Nemur's hypothesis contains an error and that there is a
possibility that his intelligence gain will only be temporary.
Charlie meets his neighbor, an attractive, free-spirited artist named Fay
Lillman. Charlie does not tell Fay about his past, and with her, he
is able to consummate a sexual relationship. After Charlie returns to the lab,
however—having been given dispensation to do his own research by the
foundation that is funding the experiment—his consuming commitment to his work
causes him to drift from Fay. Algernon's intelligence slips and his behavior
becomes erratic, and Charlie worries that whatever happens to Algernon will soon
happen to him as well. Eventually Algernon dies, and Charlie visits his mother
and sister in order to try to come to terms with his past before he regresses
into his old retarded self. The experience is moving, thrilling, and devastating
to him, as his mother—now a demented old woman—expresses pride in his
accomplishments, and his sister is overjoyed to see him. But Rose slips into a
delusional flashback, and she attacks Charlie with a butcher knife. He leaves
sobbing, but from that moment on he has transcended his painful background and
become a fully developed individual.
Charlie succeeds in finding the error in Nemur's hypothesis and proves
scientifically that because of the nature of the operation, his intelligence
will leave him as quickly as it came to him. He calls this phenomenon the "Algernon-Gordon
Effect." As he passes through a stage of average intelligence on his way
back to retardation, Charlie enjoys a brief, passionate relationship with Alice.
But he sends her away as he senses his old self returning. When Charlie's
regression is complete, he briefly returns to his old job at the bakery, where
his co-workers welcome him back with kindness. But after he upsets Alice by
mistakenly returning to her night-school class for retarded adults, having
forgotten that he is no longer enrolled in it—having forgotten, in fact, their
entire romantic relationship—Charlie decides to remove himself from the people
who have known him and now feel sorry for him. He checks himself into a home for
disabled adults. His last request is for the reader of his manuscript to leave
fresh flowers on Algernon's grave.
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
7 |
8 |
9 |
10 |
11 |
12 |
13 |
14 |
Explanation for Quotation 1
Charlie
is recounting a conversation he has with Nemur
in "progris riport 6th" shortly before his operation. Nemur cannot
guarantee Charlie that his procedure will be successful, but he is trying to
make Charlie feel good about his participation in the experiment. In trying to
impress Charlie with promises of fame and great contributions to science, Nemur
reveals what his motivations are. It is Nemur who wants his name to "go
down in the books," not Charlie. On the contrary, Charlie's reason for
wanting to be intelligent is purely social: he wants people to like him. Charlie
knows that his retardation has cut him off from most of society, but his
resultant powerlessness does not upset him. Charlie does not long to join
society so that he can increase his social standing, but, rather, he longs to
join society because, apart from it, he is lonely. Intelligence, in Charlie's
mind, is the quality that will gain him entry into a world of friends. Of
course, the resulting irony is that when Charlie does become intelligent, he
finds himself lonelier than ever before.
In Progress Report 12, Charlie flashes back to an incident with his sister Norma
in which she gets an A on a history exam and demands from her parents the dog
that they have promised her if she performed well in school. When Charlie
volunteers to help take care of the dog, Norma throws a fit and insists that the
dog be only hers—Matt
responds by saying there would be no dog for anyone in that case. In the quote
above, Norma is continuing her tantrum and petulantly threatening her parents.
She feels that Charlie is getting preferential treatment because he is retarded,
and so, she suggests that perhaps she too should become retarded. Though Norma
is being purposefully absurd, for a moment it seems that she envies Charlie's
retardation, and it is the only time in the novel where his disability is
perceived by anyone as an advantage. Of course, listening to Norma rant, Charlie
can hardly feel that he is in an enviable position: by being retarded, which he
cannot help, he seems to be making his sister miserable.
Norma's threat to lose her intelligence is meant to be ludicrous, just as
ludicrous as the notion of Charlie gaining intelligence. Of course, many years
later, Charlie does gain intelligence, and then later loses it. When Norma says,
"I don't remember anything I learned any more!" she is making a cruel
joke in order to upset her parents, but these words foreshadow exactly what will
happen to Charlie at the end of the novel.
In Progress Report 13, Charlie accompanies Nemur and Strauss
to a scientific convention in Chicago where they are presenting their findings.
Charlie and Algernon are brought along, essentially as exhibits. At this point
in the novel, Charlie has been growing increasingly upset with Nemur for
treating him not as a human being but as a laboratory animal, and here at the
convention, Charlie's feeling of victimization attains a new level of intensity.
Surrounded by a whole hall full of scientists curious to see the results of
Nemur and Strauss's experiment—as if there were hundreds of Nemurs all eyeing
him clinically—Charlie feels that he is there not so much to edify the
scientists as to entertain them. He imagines the chairman of the conference as a
carnival barker, touting Charlie and Algernon as a "side show" (the
portion of the circus where human oddities—"freaks"—are put on
display). Charlie imagines the chairman/barker callously referring to him as a
"moron," grotesquely proving that he is not the least bit concerned
with Charlie's feelings. This paranoid fantasy is the height of Charlie's sense
of objectification, and it comes shortly before he runs away from the conference
with Algernon to assert his independence.
When Charlie gains intelligence, he begins to have a sense of an
"other" Charlie—his former retarded self—who watches over him,
remaining in the back of his mind, always present. In Progress Report 14, he
goes to visit his father, Matt, hoping to talk to him and learn more about his
childhood. But Matt does not recognize Charlie, and Charlie cannot bring himself
to tell Matt who he is. In this quote, Charlie realizes why he cannot, and why
he feels he should not, reveal his identity to Matt: Charlie is no longer that
"other" self that he imagines, and therefore he is no longer the same
Charlie that was Matt's son. Though Charlie longs to connect to and understand
his past, he realizes that he has traveled too far to be able to present himself
as the same person he used to be. He believes that, rather than being happy for
his son's massive gains in intelligence, Matt would feel betrayed if he were to
learn that the articulate and bright man before him was Charlie. Charlie thinks
that Matt would feel "diminished" by Charlie's intelligence, not just
because Charlie is now far smarter than Matt is, but also because Matt had
invested so much energy into relating to his son as a retarded boy. For years,
Matt had dealt with the difficulty of having a retarded son and dealt with the
greater difficulty of trying to convince his irrational wife Rose
to accept Charlie's retardation. If all these years later, a new Charlie were to
come along and not be mentally disabled, Charlie fears, Matt would feel that he
had wasted all of his emotional energy, and feel cheated. Charlie is two people
now, but neither person can have a whole life or a whole history.
This is Charlie's second to last postscript, in his final progress report. Aware
that he is about to go live at the Warren State Home and be cut off from all of
the people he has known, he writes farewells to Alice
and Dr.
Strauss, but he saves a special word of advice for Nemur. During the
novel, Nemur has been revealed as a humorless and intensely career-focused man,
who lacks human compassion. For a time, at the height of his genius, Charlie's
own intellectual self-absorption has threatened to turn him into a similarly
cold individual. Upon discovering that his bakery co-workers used to tease him
for sport when he was retarded, Charlie became understandably angry and
embittered. He hated the idea that he was being laughed at, but now he can
accept it again.
No one has tried to play such cruel jokes on Nemur as used to be played on
Charlie, but nonetheless Nemur is insecure and fears any challenges to his
authority. Charlie comes to learn near the end of the novel that intellectual
superiority is not the most important goal of a human life, and he is able to
steer himself away from becoming like Nemur, learning to love and forgive other
people. Now, in this quote, when Charlie has fully reverted to his original
retarded state, Charlie tries to pass on some of what he has learned to Nemur—although
Charlie is no longer capable of articulately expressing his emotional
discoveries to Nemur, his words nonetheless ring with the truth of experience.
Nemur would indeed have "more frends" if he were not so focused on
maintaining a pointless sense of superiority. Charlie refers to his own
situation, as a retarded man, and Nemur's, as a university professor, with equal
applicability.
15 |
16 |
17 |